orangeleader.com (Orange, Texas)

Top Stories

October 22, 2012

Texas schools head to trial over school finance

AUSTIN — Texas lawmakers cut $5.4 billion from public schools nearly 18 months ago, and now districts are headed to court to argue that the resulting system is so inefficient and unfair that it violates the state constitution.

Simply restoring funding to levels prior to the 2011 legislative session won't be enough to fix the fundamentally flawed way Texas funds its schools, lawyers for the districts say. They point out that the cuts have come even as the state requires schools to prepare students for standardized tests that are getting more difficult, and amid a statewide boom in the number of low-income students that are especially costly to educate.

Putting the money back would make things easier, they say.

"That's not all it's about, but that would be a start," said John Turner, an attorney representing about 60 of the school districts suing.

The trial starts Monday in the Austin courtroom of Texas District Judge John Dietz and is expected to last into January. It is the sixth legal battle of its kind since 1984 and involves six lawsuits filed since last October on behalf of about two-thirds of Texas school districts, which in turn educate around 75 percent of the state's roughly 5 million students.

The largest group of plaintiffs is led by the Fort Bend Independent School District outside Houston but includes districts from Amarillo to Abilene to Austin and most points in between, as well as Dallas, Houston, and San Antonio schools.

Districts both in rich and poor parts of the state are on the same side of the case. Texas' funding system relies heavily on property taxes and a "Robin Hood" scheme in which districts with high property values or abundant tax revenue from oil or natural gas resources turn over part of the money they raise to poorer districts.

Many "property wealthy" districts say that while they are in better shape than their poorer counterparts, the system still starves them of funding since local voters who would otherwise support property tax increases to bolster funding for their schools refuse to do so, knowing that most of the money would be sent somewhere else.

Also suing are charter schools, who want state funding for their facilities, and a small number of parents.

All argue that the system defies the Texas Constitution, which promises "a general diffusion of knowledge" by an "efficient system of public free schools."

Texas Attorney General Greg Abbott's office places the blame on individual districts.

"Given the fact that the public education system is founded on local control, success or failure of a school district is necessarily linked to the school district's own leadership, polices and operations," the office said in pretrial brief. "If a local school district fails to provide its students a general diffusion of knowledge, such a result, while unacceptable, does not render the entire public school system unsuitable."

Whatever Dietz decides is likely to be appealed to the state Supreme Court. If the courts rule against the state, it will be up to the Legislature to remake the system — but a high-court ruling may not come in time to tackle the issue during next year's legislative session, said David Thompson, lead attorney for the group of plaintiffs led by the Fort Bend district.

Thompson said "there is no magic bullet" for fixing school finance in Texas, but added, "I would hope, if nothing else, we don't see additional cuts."

Abbott's office stands little chance of prevailing, if history is any guide.

The Texas Supreme Court ruled in 1989 that the school finance system was unconstitutional because students in rich and poor districts alike "must be afforded a substantially equal opportunity to have access to educational funds." After subsequent overhauls by the Legislature, the high court again found the school finance systems unconstitutional in 1991, 1992 and 2005.

In 2006, the Legislature cut local school property taxes by one-third and aimed to make up for it with state funding from a business margin tax that by some calculations has created a school funding shortfall of $6 billion annually.

Then, looking to plug gaping budget holes last year, the Legislature cut $4 billion in spending for schools and $1.4 billion in grant programs, causing per-student funding to fall more than $500 last year — even while enrollment is increasing by 80,000 students annually. District superintendents say they've laid off teachers and increased class sizes to cope with the cuts.

Enrollment growth has been almost entirely fueled by students from low-income families who cost more on average to educate. Last year, more than 60 percent of Texas students qualified for free or reduced-price lunches, and 17 percent of students statewide have limited proficiency in English at best — requiring more spending on bilingual programs.

Meanwhile, the state has introduced a new, more rigorous standardized testing system designed to better prepare students for college. Budget cuts have left less money for schools to spend getting their students ready for them, or providing remedial instruction for those who don't pass.

"You can't give us the mission," Thompson said, "then not give us the tools to accomplish that mission."

 

Text Only
Top Stories
  • Big 4 cellphone carriers unite on anti-texting ads

    The country's four biggest cellphone companies are set to launch their first joint advertising campaign against texting while driving, uniting behind AT&T's "It Can Wait" slogan to blanket TV and radio this summer.

    May 19, 2013

  • Jolie.jpg Details of Jolie's breast treatment revealed

    Angelina Jolie's mother had breast cancer and died of ovarian cancer, and her maternal grandmother also had ovarian cancer — strong evidence of an inherited, genetic risk that led the actress to have both of her healthy breasts removed to try to avoid the same fate, her doctor said Wednesday.

    May 17, 2013 1 Photo

  • Jolie admired for bravery in mastectomy revelation

    "I hope that other women can benefit from my experience," Angelina Jolie wrote in a powerful op-ed article Tuesday, explaining her decision to go public with having her breasts removed to avoid cancer.

    May 15, 2013

  • 2013 deficit estimate lowered to $642 billion

    The budget deficit for the current year is projected to come in well below what was estimated just a few months ago, a development that could further curb the already slowing momentum for a budget pact this year.

    May 15, 2013

  • Bed Sharing Safely.jpg Bed Sharing Safely: Not All Co-Sleeping is Created Equal

    Breastfeeding Significantly Reduces SIDS Risk

    May 13, 2013 1 Photo 1 Story

  • Security fence erected where Ohio women held

    An imposing, 10-foot privacy fence has been erected around the home of a Cleveland rape and kidnapping suspect charged with holding three women captive for about a decade.

    May 13, 2013

  • Police vow to solve shootings of 19 in New Orleans

    Video released early Monday by New Orleans police shows a possible suspect in the Mother's Day gunfire that wounded 19 people during a neighborhood parade.

    May 13, 2013

  • Sea World.jpg SeaWorld adds new shows for summer fun

    On Saturday, June 8, three all-new shows will debut at SeaWorld San Antonio as the park begins its annual “Summer Nights” series.

    May 12, 2013 1 Photo

  • Study: Per Capita Rx Spending Fell For First Time In 2012

    Americans’ per capita spending on prescription drugs fell last year for the first time on record, according to a report released Thursday by the IMS Institute For Healthcare Informatics firm headquartered in Danbury, Conn., which tracks pharmaceutical sales and other health care data.

    May 12, 2013

  • Texas man's mission: Honoring WWII Monuments Men

    After selling his Dallas oil and gas company and moving to Europe, Robert Edsel found himself in the art-drenched Italian city of Florence. Standing on the city's famous medieval covered bridge — the Ponte Vecchio — he began to contemplate how so many famous sites and works of art in Europe survived the destruction of World War II.

    May 10, 2013

Community Calendar
Loading…
Events by eviesays.com
Hyperlocal Search
Premier Guide
Find a business

Walking Fingers
Maps, Menus, Store hours, Coupons, and more...
Premier Guide